Statistical analysis and plots

Load R libraries (install first from CRAN or Bioconductor)

library(WGCNA) # Gene networks - needs 'impute' dependency: source("https://bioconductor.org/biocLite.R"); biocLite("impute")
library(RSQLite) # Access SQLite databases
library(reshape2) # data tidying (melt)
library(dplyr) # data tidying
library(tidyr) # data tidying
library(purrr) # manipulate lists
library(stringr) # string manipulation
library(ggplot2) # for plots
library(ggrepel) # for plots
library(ggdendro) # for plots
library(gridExtra) # for plots
library(grid) # for plots
library(RColorBrewer) # for plots
library(ggjoy) # for plots
library(gplots) # Venn diagram
library(ecodist) # for nmds
library(MuMIn) # for model comparison
library(sva) # for ComBat function; install via source("https://bioconductor.org/biocLite.R"); biocLite("sva")
library(pander) # for nice tables
library(kableExtra) # For scrollable tables
library(clusterProfiler) # for enrichment tests; source("https://bioconductor.org/biocLite.R"); biocLite("clusterProfiler") 
library(fgsea) # for enrichment tests; source("https://bioconductor.org/biocLite.R"); biocLite("fgsea") 
select <- dplyr::select
filter <- dplyr::filter
rename <- dplyr::rename

kable.table <- function(df) {
  kable(df, "html") %>%
  kable_styling() %>%
  scroll_box(height = "300px")
}

# Open database connections (Sasha uses SQL, Luke prefers dplyr)
db <- dbConnect(SQLite(), dbname="data/queen_pheromone.db")
my_db <- src_sqlite("data/queen_pheromone.db")

# These 4 samples should NOT be used (See below). They were also removed in all non-R analyses (e.g. differential gene expression analyses using EBseq)
bad.samples <- c("lf1", "ln1", "ln12", "lf12")

First let’s check for and remove strongly outlying samples

  # Define a function to get gene expression data for a given set of orthologous genes. We define orthologous genes as those that are each other's reciprocal best BLAST. The bad.samples argument can be used to remove some named samples. By default this function logs the expression data (using log10). It returns a list with two elements: the first element is a matrix of expression data (rows = samples, cols = genes), and the second is a data frame giving the species-specific names of the orthologous genes
make.OGGs <- function(species, bad.samples = NULL, log.data = T){
  
  # set up forward mappings, e.g. "am2bt", "am2lf", "am2ln"
  forward.mappings <- paste(species[1], "2", species[2:length(species)], sep = "")
  # and reverse mappings, e.g. "bt2am", "lf2am", "ln2am"
  backward.mappings <- paste(species[2:length(species)], "2", species[1], sep = "")
  items <- list() # declare empty list

  for(i in 1:length(forward.mappings)){
    
    # make a table with 3 columns: first column has species 1 gene,
    # second column has species 2 gene in forward mapping,
    # third column has species 2 gene in reverse mapping (this can be NA, or different to col 2)
    # we want the rows where cols 2 and 3 are the same, indicating reciprocity in the BLAST
    focal <- left_join(
      tbl(my_db, forward.mappings[i]) %>% 
        dplyr::select(-evalue), # get the two mappings and 
      tbl(my_db, backward.mappings[i]) %>% 
        dplyr::select(-evalue), # merge by species 1 column
      by = species[1]
    ) %>% 
      collect(n=Inf) %>% as.data.frame  # collect it all and convert to df
    
    # Get the RBB rows, and keep the two relevant columns
    focal <- focal[!is.na(focal[,3]), ]
    items[[i]] <- focal[focal[,2] == focal[,3], 1:2] 
  }
  rbbs <- items[[1]] # If 3 or 4 species, successively merge the results
  if(length(items) > 1) rbbs <- left_join(rbbs, items[[2]], by = species[1])
  if(length(items) > 2) rbbs <- left_join(rbbs, items[[3]], by = species[1])
  
  # Throw out species1 genes that do not have a RBB in all species
  rbbs <- rbbs[complete.cases(rbbs), ]
  names(rbbs) <- gsub("[.]x", "", names(rbbs)) # tidy the row and column names
  rownames(rbbs) <- NULL

  # Make sure the columns are ordered as in 'species'
  rbbs <- rbbs[, match(names(rbbs), species)]

  # We know have a list of the names of all the ortholgous genes in each species
  # Now we use these names to look up the gene expression data for each ortholog
  expression.tables <- paste("rsem_", species, sep = "")
  
  for(i in 1:length(species)){
    focal.expression <- tbl(my_db, expression.tables[i]) %>% 
      collect(n=Inf) %>% as.data.frame()
    names(focal.expression)[names(focal.expression) == "gene"] <- species[i]
    rbbs <- left_join(rbbs, focal.expression, by = species[i])
  }
  gene.name.mappings <- rbbs[, names(rbbs) %in% species] # save gene name mappings in separate DF
  
  rownames(rbbs) <- rbbs[,1] # Use the gene names for species 1 as row names
  rbbs <- rbbs[, !(names(rbbs) %in% species)] # remove gene name columns 
  rbbs <- t(as.matrix(rbbs))

  if(log.data) rbbs <- log10(1 + rbbs)
  if(!is.null(bad.samples)) rbbs <- rbbs[!(rownames(rbbs) %in% bad.samples), ]
  
  # Discard genes where NAs appear
  gene.name.mappings <- gene.name.mappings[!(is.na(colSums(rbbs))), ]
  rbbs <- rbbs[, !(is.na(colSums(rbbs)))]

  # discard genes where expression is zero for all samples in 1 or more species
  spp <- str_replace_all(rownames(rbbs), "[:digit:]", "")
  to.keep <- rep(TRUE, ncol(rbbs))
  for(i in 1:ncol(rbbs)){
   if(min(as.numeric(tapply(rbbs[,i], spp, sum))) == 0) to.keep[i] <- FALSE
 }
rbbs <- rbbs[, to.keep]
gene.name.mappings <- gene.name.mappings[to.keep, ]

  list(tpm = rbbs, gene.mappings = gene.name.mappings)
}

set.seed(1) # nmds involves random numbers, so make this plot reproducible
expression.data <- make.OGGs(c("am", "bt", "ln", "lf"))[[1]]
treatments <- tbl(my_db, "treatments") %>% as.data.frame()

shhh <- capture.output(nmds.output <- dist(expression.data) %>% nmds())
fig_S1 <- data.frame(id = rownames(expression.data), nmds.output$conf[[length(nmds.output$conf)]], stringsAsFactors = F) %>%
  left_join(treatments, by = "id") %>% 
  rename(Species = species, Treatment = treatment) %>%
  ggplot(aes(X1,X2, shape = Species)) + 
  geom_point(aes(colour = Treatment)) + 
  geom_text_repel(aes(label = id), size=3.6) + 
  xlab("NMDS 1") + ylab("NMDS 2")

saveRDS(fig_S1, file = "supplement/fig_S1.rds")
fig_S1

set.seed(1) # nmds involves random numbers, so make this plot reproducible
expression.data <- make.OGGs(c("am", "bt", "ln", "lf"), bad.samples = bad.samples)[[1]]

shhh <- capture.output(nmds.output <- dist(expression.data) %>% nmds())
fig_S2 <- data.frame(id = rownames(expression.data), 
           nmds.output$conf[[length(nmds.output$conf)]], 
           stringsAsFactors = F) %>%
  left_join(treatments, by = "id") %>%
  rename(Species = species, Treatment = treatment) %>% 
  ggplot(aes(X1,X2)) + 
  geom_point(aes(shape = Species, colour = Treatment)) + 
  geom_text_repel(aes(label = id), size=3.6) + 
  xlab("NMDS 1") + ylab("NMDS 2")

saveRDS(fig_S2, file = "supplement/fig_S2.rds")
fig_S2

Table of sample sizes

Table S1: Number of sequencing libraries for each combination of species and treatment, after removing the four problematic libraries. Each library was prepared from a pool containing equal amounts of cDNA from five individual workers, taken from the same colony.

sample.size.table <- treatments[treatments$id %in% rownames(expression.data),] %>% 
  group_by(species, treatment) %>% 
  summarise(n = n()) %>% as.data.frame()
names(sample.size.table) <- c("Species", "Treatment", "Number of RNAseq libraries")

saveRDS(sample.size.table, file = "supplement/tab_S1.rds")
sample.size.table %>% pander()

Genes that are differentially expressed in multiple species

In Tables S6-S7, we have simply listed the genes that showed statistically significant differential expression in two or more species. This method is expected to make few ‘false positive’ errors, but it probably misses many of true overlaps because our study has modest power to detect differential expression (that is, the ‘false negative’ rate is high).

In Table S8, we instead look for similarities between species using a method that ranks genes from most- to least- phermone sensitive based on log fold change, alleviating the problem of low power. To do this, we select the top \(n\) genes per species (where \(n\) = 100, 200… 500), based on the absolute magnitude of the log fold-change response to queen pheromone, giving a list of the most pheromone-sensitive genes. This method produces fewer false negatives in our search for overlapping genes, at cost of increasing the false positive rate.

# Define a function to test whether the overlap of two sets of differentially expressed genes, 
# drawn from a common pool (e.g. all the orthologs that were tested), is higher or lower than expected
# Inspiration for this code: https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/10328/using-rs-phyper-to-get-the-probability-of-list-overlap
overlap.hypergeometric.test <- function(n.overlaps, num.sig1, num.sig2, num.genes, species){
  p.smaller <- phyper(n.overlaps, num.sig1, num.genes - num.sig1, num.sig2) 
  p.higher <- 1 - phyper(n.overlaps - 1, num.sig1, num.genes - num.sig1, num.sig2)
  percent_of_maximum_overlaps <- 100 * n.overlaps / min(c(num.sig1, num.sig2))
  output <- data.frame(Species = species,
                       Test = c("Overlap is lower than expected:",
                                  "Overlap is higher than expected:"),
                       p = c(p.smaller, p.higher),
                       percent_of_maximum_overlaps = round(percent_of_maximum_overlaps,1))
  output[output$p == min(output$p), ]
}



# Apis and flavus
af.oggs <- make.OGGs(c("am", "lf"))[[2]] # Get the orthologous gene list
n.am <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_am") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% af.oggs$am) %>% 
           summarise(n=n()) %>% 
           as.data.frame())[1,1] # Count the number of diff expressed genes that appear in the OGG list
n.lf <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_lf") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% af.oggs$lf) %>% summarise(n=n()) %>% 
           as.data.frame())[1,1]
num.oggs.af <- nrow(af.oggs) # Count the orthologous genes
af.oggs <- suppressMessages(
  af.oggs %>% 
    filter(am %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_am") %>% 
                      as.data.frame())[,1],
           lf %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_lf") %>% 
                      as.data.frame())[,1]) %>% 
    mutate(Species = "Apis and L. flavus") %>% 
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(am=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`Apis FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(lf=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`L. flavus FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>% 
                rename(am=gene), copy=T))
num.overlap.af <- nrow(af.oggs) # Count the overlaps
test1 <- overlap.hypergeometric.test(num.overlap.af, 
                                     n.am, n.lf, 
                                     num.oggs.af, 
                                     "Apis and L. flavus") # Run the hypergeometric test


# Apis and niger
an.oggs <- make.OGGs(c("am", "ln"))[[2]] # Get the orthologous gene list
n.am <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_am") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% an.oggs$am) %>% 
           summarise(n=n()) %>% as.data.frame())[1,1] # Count the number of diff expressed genes that appear in the OGG list
n.ln <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_ln") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% an.oggs$ln) %>% 
           summarise(n=n()) %>% as.data.frame())[1,1]
num.oggs.an <- nrow(an.oggs) # Count the orthologous genes
an.oggs <- suppressMessages(
  an.oggs %>% 
    filter(am %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_am") %>% as.data.frame())[,1],
           ln %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_ln") %>% as.data.frame())[,1]) %>% 
    mutate(Species = "Apis and L. niger") %>% 
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(am=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`Apis FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(ln=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`L. niger FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>% 
                rename(am=gene), copy=T))
num.overlap.an <- nrow(an.oggs) # Count the overlaps
test2 <- overlap.hypergeometric.test(num.overlap.an, n.am, n.ln, num.oggs.an, "Apis and L. niger") # Run the hypergeometric test

# flavus and niger
fn.oggs <- make.OGGs(c("lf", "ln"))[[2]] # Get the orthologous gene list
n.lf <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_lf") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% fn.oggs$lf) %>%
           summarise(n=n()) %>% as.data.frame())[1,1] # Count the number of diff expressed genes that appear in the OGG list
n.ln <- (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_ln") %>% 
           filter(gene %in% fn.oggs$ln) %>% 
           summarise(n=n()) %>% as.data.frame())[1,1]
num.oggs.fn <- nrow(fn.oggs) # Count the orthologous genes
fn.oggs <- suppressMessages(
  fn.oggs %>% filter(ln %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_ln") %>% as.data.frame())[,1],
                     lf %in% (tbl(my_db, "ebseq_padj_gene_lf") %>% as.data.frame())[,1]) %>% 
    mutate(Species = "L. flavus and L. niger") %>% 
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(lf=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`L. flavus FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% 
                dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
                rename(ln=gene), copy=T) %>% 
    rename(`L. niger FC` = PostFC) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "lf2am"), copy=T) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>% 
                rename(am=gene), copy=T))
num.missing <- sum(is.na(fn.oggs$name))
fn.oggs$name[is.na(fn.oggs$name)] <- paste("Unknown gene", 1:num.missing)
num.overlap.fn <- nrow(fn.oggs) # Count the overlaps
test3 <- overlap.hypergeometric.test(num.overlap.fn, 
                                     n.lf, n.ln, 
                                     num.oggs.fn, 
                                     "L. flavus and L. niger") # Run the hypergeometric test


overlaps <- suppressMessages(
  data.frame(name = unique(c(af.oggs$name, an.oggs$name, fn.oggs$name)), 
             stringsAsFactors = F) %>%
    left_join(rbind(af.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, starts_with("Apis")),
                    an.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, starts_with("Apis")))) %>%
    left_join(rbind(af.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, ends_with("flavus FC")),
                    fn.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, ends_with("flavus FC")))) %>%
    left_join(rbind(an.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, ends_with("niger FC")),
                    fn.oggs %>% dplyr::select(name, ends_with("niger FC")))) %>% distinct())
overlaps <- rbind(overlaps[overlaps$name == "myosin light chain alkali-like isoform X5", ],
                  overlaps[overlaps$name != "myosin light chain alkali-like isoform X5", ])
overlaps$Consistent <- "Yes"
overlaps$Consistent[apply(overlaps[,2:4],1,min,na.rm=T)<1 & apply(overlaps[,2:4],1,max,na.rm=T)>1] <- "No"
for(i in 2:4) overlaps[,i] <- format(round(log2(overlaps[,i]), 3), nsmall = 3) 
overlaps[overlaps == "    NA"] <- " "
rownames(overlaps) <- NULL

overlap.p.values <- rbind(test1, test2, test3) 
rownames(overlap.p.values) <- NULL

all.overlaps <- c(af.oggs$am, an.oggs$am, fn.oggs$am[!is.na(fn.oggs$am)]) %>% unique

Table S6: All orthologous genes that were significantly differentially expressed between pheromone treatments in more than one species. The FC columns give the Log\(_2\) fold-change in expression for each species where the focal gene was significantly differentially expressed, where positive numbers mean it was expressed at a higher level in control animals. The last column highlights genes that responded to treatment in a consistent or inconsistent direction across species. B. terrestris is omitted because neither of its differentially expressed genes were significantly affected by treatment in the other three species.

saveRDS(overlaps, file = "supplement/tab_S6.rds")
kable.table(overlaps)

Table S7: The overlap between the lists of significantly differently expressed orthologous genes was significantly higher than expected for L. flavus and L. niger, suggesting that queen pheromone has conserved effects on gene expression between these two species (results based on a hypergeometric test). For the other two species pairs, the number of overlapping genes was not higher or lower than expected under the null hypothesis that queen pheromone affects a random set of genes in each species. The last column gives the number of genes that overlapped, divided by the maximum number that could have overlapped given the numbers of orthologous genes that were significant in each species.

names(overlap.p.values)[4] <- "% of maximum possible overlap" 
saveRDS(overlap.p.values, file = "supplement/tab_S7.rds")
pander(overlap.p.values, split.cell = 40, split.table = Inf)

most.pheromone.sensitive.genes <- function(){
  ngenes.list <- (1:5)*100 # 100 - 500
  
  overlapping_genes <- list()
  permutation_results <- list()
  for(i in 1:length(ngenes.list)){
    ngenes <- ngenes.list[i]
    
    # Get the top n genes from Apis, as ranked by the absolute value for the log-fold change in response to pheromone
    g1 <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% collect() %>% 
      dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
      mutate(PostFC = log2(PostFC)) %>% left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), copy=TRUE, by = "gene") %>% 
      arrange(-abs(PostFC)) 
    
    # Do the same for genes from non-Apis species, and get the Apis names for the top BLAST hits in the Apis genome
    g2 <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_bt") %>% 
      dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "bt2am") %>% 
                  rename(gene = bt) %>% 
                  dplyr::select(-evalue), by = "gene") %>%
      collect() %>% mutate(PostFC = log2(PostFC)) %>% 
      arrange(-abs(PostFC)) %>% 
      rename(bt = gene, gene = am) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), copy=TRUE, by = "gene") %>% 
      filter(!is.na(name)) 
    
    g3 <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% 
      dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "lf2am") %>% 
                  rename(gene = lf) %>% 
                  dplyr::select(-evalue), by = "gene") %>%
      collect() %>% mutate(PostFC = log2(PostFC)) %>% 
      arrange(-abs(PostFC)) %>% 
      rename(lf = gene, gene = am) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), copy=TRUE, by = "gene") %>% 
      filter(!is.na(name)) 
    
    g4 <-tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% 
      dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "ln2am") %>% 
                  rename(gene = ln) %>% 
                  dplyr::select(-evalue), by = "gene") %>%
      collect() %>% mutate(PostFC = log2(PostFC)) %>% 
      arrange(-abs(PostFC)) %>% 
      rename(ln = gene, gene = am) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), copy=TRUE, by = "gene") %>% 
      filter(!is.na(name)) 
    
    get_top <- function(x, ngenes) {x %>% head(ngenes) %>% .$name %>% unique()}
    
    # Count the number of intersections, and find gene names that appear in 3 or 4 species using the venn() function
    venn.diagram <- venn(list(am=(g1 %>% get_top(ngenes)), 
                              bt=(g2 %>% get_top(ngenes)), 
                              lf=(g3 %>% get_top(ngenes)), 
                              ln=(g4 %>% get_top(ngenes))), show.plot=FALSE) 
    three.plus <- attr(venn.diagram, "intersections")[str_count(names(attr(venn.diagram, "intersections")), ":") > 1] %>% 
      unlist %>% unname %>% unique %>% sort
    four <- attr(venn.diagram, "intersections")[str_count(names(attr(venn.diagram, "intersections")), ":") > 2] %>% 
      unlist %>% unname %>% unique %>% sort
    three <- three.plus[!(three.plus %in% four)]
    if(length(three) + length(four) > 0) overlapping_genes[[i]] <- data.frame(Name = c(three, four), 
                                                                              count = c(rep("x3 species", length(three)), 
                                                                                        rep("4 species", length(four))), 
                                                                              nGenes = ngenes, stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
    
    count_intersects <- function(l1, l2) {
      
      intersections <- attr(venn(list(am=l1 %>% get_top(ngenes), 
                                      bt=l2 %>% get_top(ngenes)), 
                                 show.plot=FALSE), "intersections")
      if(length(intersections) > 2) return(length(intersections[[3]]))
      else return(0)
      
    }
    
    # permutation test
    num_overlaps <- c(count_intersects(g1,g2), count_intersects(g1,g3), count_intersects(g1,g4),
                      count_intersects(g2,g3), count_intersects(g2,g4), count_intersects(g3,g4))
    
    nBoots <- 10000
    boot_results <- lapply(1:nBoots, function(x){
      g1 <- g1[sample(nrow(g1), nrow(g1)), ]
      g2 <- g2[sample(nrow(g2), nrow(g2)), ]
      g3 <- g3[sample(nrow(g3), nrow(g3)), ]
      g4 <- g4[sample(nrow(g4), nrow(g4)), ]
      
      c(count_intersects(g1,g2), count_intersects(g1,g3), count_intersects(g1,g4),
        count_intersects(g2,g3), count_intersects(g2,g4), count_intersects(g3,g4))
      
    }) %>% do.call("rbind", .) 
    
    p <- 1:6
    for(j in 1:6) p[j] <- sum(boot_results[,j] > num_overlaps[j]) / nBoots
    
    permutation_results[[i]] <- tibble(species_pair = c("am-bt", "am-lf", "am-ln", "bt-lf", "bt-ln", "lf-ln"),
                                       top_n_genes = ngenes.list[i],
                                       observed_overlaps = num_overlaps,
                                       expected_overlaps = colMeans(boot_results),
                                       `O/E` = observed_overlaps / expected_overlaps,
                                       p = p,
                                       x = ifelse(p < 0.05, "sig", " ")) %>% as.data.frame()
  } # end of for()

  permutation_results <- do.call("rbind", permutation_results)
  names(permutation_results) <- c("Species pair", "Size of gene set", "Obs. overlaps", "Exp. overlaps", "O/E", "p-value", "")
  
  overlapping_genes <- do.call("rbind", overlapping_genes) %>%
    arrange(count, nGenes, Name) %>%
    distinct(paste(Name, count), .keep_all = TRUE) %>%
    dplyr::select(Name, count, nGenes) %>%
    mutate(count = replace(count, count == "x3 species", "3 species")) 
  
  names(overlapping_genes) <- c("Name", "Appears in", "Size of gene set")
  list(overlapping_genes, permutation_results)
}

if(!("most.pheromone.sensitive.genes.rds" %in% list.files("data"))){
  most.pheromone.sensitive.genes <- most.pheromone.sensitive.genes()
  saveRDS(most.pheromone.sensitive.genes, "data/most.pheromone.sensitive.genes.rds")
} else {
  most.pheromone.sensitive.genes <- readRDS("data/most.pheromone.sensitive.genes.rds")
}

Table S8: List of genes that appear in the top n-most pheromone-sensitive genes for 3 or 4 species. To generate the table, we ranked genes by the absolute value of their log fold change in response to queen pheromone, then listed the gene names that appeared in 3-4 species. For non-Apis species, we found the gene names by comparison with the Apis genome by BLAST. This exercise was performed with n = 100, 200 … 500, and the third column lists the smallest n for which the gene in question appeared (for example, the gene protein takeout-like appeared for all 4 species when inspecting the top 200+ genes).

saveRDS(most.pheromone.sensitive.genes[[1]], file = "supplement/tab_S8.rds")
kable(most.pheromone.sensitive.genes[[1]], "html") %>%
  kable_styling() %>%
  scroll_box(height = "300px")

Table S9: Results of a permutation test examining the number of overlaps in the top n-most pheromone-sensitive genes for each pair of species. To generate the table, we ranked genes by the absolute value of their log fold change in response to queen pheromone, then took the top n-most pheromone-sensitive genes for each species, and counted the observed and expected number of overlaps (the expected number was estimated by bootstrapping with 10^5 replicates). The O/E column gives the ratio of observed to expected, where numbers >1 indicate more overlap than expected. The one-tailed p-value was estimated as the proportion of bootstrap replicates showing more overlap than in the real dataset. This exercise was performed with n = 100, 200 … 500.

saveRDS(most.pheromone.sensitive.genes[[2]], file = "supplement/tab_S9.rds")
kable(most.pheromone.sensitive.genes[[2]], "html", digits=2) %>%
  kable_styling() %>%
  scroll_box(height = "300px")

Correlations in pheromone-sensitive gene expression across species

These tests ask if pairs of orthologous genes tend to show a similar level of pheromone sensitivity across species. These tests ask whether there is a cross-species correlation in absolute log fold change in response to pheromone treatment, as calculated using ebseq. The advantage of these tests is that one is not limited to focusing on the set of ‘significant’ genes (as with the Venn diagrams shown in Figure 1), which discards a lot of information becuase it uses an arbitrary p-value threshold, and puts all the genes into two bins (ignoring the quantitative differences in fold-change).

get.fc.for.pair.species <- function(species1, species2){
  query <- 'SELECT rbb.X AS X_gene, rbb.Y AS Y_gene, ebseq_gene_X.PostFC AS X_fc, ebseq_gene_Y.PostFC AS Y_fc FROM ebseq_gene_X
             JOIN
  (SELECT Y2X.X, Y2X.Y  FROM Y2X
  JOIN X2Y
  ON Y2X.Y = X2Y.Y AND Y2X.X = X2Y.X  ) AS rbb
  ON rbb.X = ebseq_gene_X.gene
  JOIN ebseq_gene_Y
  ON rbb.Y = ebseq_gene_Y.gene'
  
  query <- str_replace_all(query, "X", species1)
  query <- str_replace_all(query, "Y", species2)
  dbGetQuery(db, query)
}

species.combinations <- t(combn(c("am", "bt", "lf", "ln"), 2))
rho <- numeric(nrow(species.combinations))
p <- numeric(nrow(species.combinations))
for(i in 1:nrow(species.combinations)){
  fc.data <- get.fc.for.pair.species(species.combinations[i, 1], 
                                     species.combinations[i, 2])
  fc.data[,3:4] <- fc.data[,3:4] %>% log2 %>% abs # Log the fold changes - not that it matters for Spearman's!
  results <- suppressWarnings(with(fc.data, cor.test(fc.data[,3], 
                                                     fc.data[,4], method="spearman"))) # Spearman's correlation
  rho[i] <- results$estimate
  p[i] <- results$p.value
}

species.combinations <- data.frame(Species1 = species.combinations[,1],
                                   Species2  = species.combinations[,2],
                                   rho = rho,
                                   p = p.adjust(p, method = "BH"), # adjust these p-vals for multiple testing
                                   sig = " ", stringsAsFactors = F)

species.combinations[species.combinations == "am"] <- "Apis mellifera"
species.combinations[species.combinations == "bt"] <- "Bombus terrestris"
species.combinations[species.combinations == "lf"] <- "Lasius flavus"
species.combinations[species.combinations == "ln"] <- "Lasius niger"

species.combinations$sig[species.combinations$p < 0.05] <- "*"
species.combinations$sig[species.combinations$p < 0.01] <- "**"
species.combinations$sig[species.combinations$p < 0.0001] <- "***"
# Make a table
saveRDS(species.combinations %>% mutate(rho = format(round(rho, 3), nsmall = 3)), file = "supplement/tab_S10.rds")
species.combinations %>% mutate(rho = format(round(rho, 3), nsmall = 3)) %>% pander

# Make a heat map showing the correlations
heat.map.figure <- species.combinations %>% ggplot(aes(Species1, Species2, fill=rho)) + 
  geom_tile(colour="white", size = 4) + 
  scale_fill_gradient2(name = "Corr", 
                       low = brewer.pal(9, "RdYlBu")[7], 
                       mid = "white", 
                       high = brewer.pal(9, "RdYlBu")[2]) + 
  geom_text(aes(label = paste(format(signif(rho, 2), nsmall = 2), sig)), size = 3.5) +
  theme_bw() + theme(panel.grid = element_blank(), 
                     panel.border = element_blank(), 
                     axis.ticks = element_blank(), 
                     axis.text = element_text(face = "italic"), 
                     legend.position = "none") + 
  xlab(NULL) + ylab(NULL) +
  scale_x_discrete(labels = c("Apis\nmellifera", "Bombus\nterrestris", "Lasius\nflavus"), expand = c(0,0)) + 
  scale_y_discrete(labels = c("Bombus\nterrestris", "Lasius\nflavus", "Lasius\nniger"), expand = c(0,0)) 
heat.map.figure

ggsave(heat.map.figure, file = "figures/Correlations heat map.pdf", height = 4, width=4.3)

# Make a scatterplot showing the correlations
combos <- t(combn(c("am", "bt", "lf", "ln"), 2))
scatter_plot_data <- list()

for(i in 1:nrow(combos)){
  fc.data <- get.fc.for.pair.species(combos[i, 1], 
                                     combos[i, 2])
  fc.data <- fc.data[,3:4] %>% log2 %>% abs # Log the fold changes
  names(fc.data) <- c("x", "y")
  scatter_plot_data[[i]] <- data.frame(fc.data, sp1 = species.combinations[i, 1], sp2 = species.combinations[i, 2])
}

fig_S3 <- scatter_plot_data %>% 
  do.call("rbind", .) %>% 
  ggplot(aes(x, y)) + 
  geom_point(alpha = 0.15) +
  stat_smooth(method = "lm", colour = "tomato") +
  facet_wrap(~paste(sp1, sp2, sep = " v "), scales = "free", ncol = 2) + 
  labs(x = "Pheromone sensitivity of ortholog in species 1",
       y = "Pheromone sensitivity of ortholog in species 2") + 
  theme_minimal()

saveRDS(fig_S3, file = "supplement/fig_S3.rds")
fig_S3

Identifying genes that splice differently following queen pheromone treatment

Many genes showed alternative splicing in all four species, with the great majority showing between 1 and 6 isoforms.

fig_S4 <- rbind(my_db %>% tbl("isoforms_am") %>% collect %>% .$gene %>%
        table %>% melt %>% dplyr::select(value) %>% mutate(sp = "Apis mellifera"),
      my_db %>% tbl("isoforms_bt") %>% collect %>% .$gene %>%
        table %>% melt %>% dplyr::select(value) %>% mutate(sp = "Bombus terrestris"),
      my_db %>% tbl("isoforms_lf") %>% collect %>% .$gene %>%
        table %>% melt %>% dplyr::select(value) %>% mutate(sp = "Lasius niger"),
      my_db %>% tbl("isoforms_ln") %>% collect %>% .$gene %>%
        table %>% melt %>% dplyr::select(value) %>% mutate(sp = "Lasius flavus")) %>%
  as.data.frame() %>%
  ggplot(aes(x = value, y = sp, fill = sp)) +
  geom_joy(stat = "binline", binwidth=1) +
  coord_cartesian(xlim=c(1,12)) +
  scale_fill_cyclical(values = c("#4040B0", "#9090F0")) +
  scale_x_continuous(breaks = seq(1,12,by=1)) +
  scale_y_discrete(expand = c(0.01, 0)) +
  theme_joy() +
  xlab("Number of isoforms") + ylab(NULL) +
  theme(axis.text = element_text(face = "italic"))

saveRDS(fig_S4, file = "supplement/fig_S4.rds")
fig_S4

Past versions of unnamed-chunk-17-1.png

Figure S4: Distribution of isoform numbers per gene for each of the four species.

# Define a function to search for significantly alternatively spliced genes. We define these as genes that have at least two differentially expressed isoforms, where queen pheromone stimulates expresison of one isoform but surpresses expression of another
find.alternatively.spliced.genes <- function(species){

  # Write a database query with 'X' as a placeholder for the species name
  # We want to find genes in which at least two isoforms are differentially expressed in response to pheromones
  # Significant isoforms are listed in the ebseq_padj_isoform_X tables, so we count them and get the names of their genes
  query <- 'SELECT isoforms_X.gene, isoforms_X.isoform, PostFC FROM isoforms_X
JOIN
             (SELECT gene, COUNT(*) FROM ebseq_padj_isoform_X
             JOIN isoforms_X
             ON isoforms_X.isoform = ebseq_padj_isoform_X.isoform
             GROUP BY gene
             HAVING COUNT(*)>1 ) AS multiISO
             ON multiIso.gene = isoforms_X.gene
             JOIN ebseq_padj_isoform_X
             ON ebseq_padj_isoform_X.isoform = isoforms_X.isoform
             ORDER BY isoforms_X.gene'
  query <- str_replace_all(query, "X", species) # replace X with the species
  Splice <- dbGetQuery(db, query) # run the query

  # Find the highest and lowest fold change for the isoforms of each gene
  SpliceMin <- aggregate(Splice$PostFC, by=list(Splice$gene), FUN="min")
  SpliceMax <- aggregate(Splice$PostFC, by=list(Splice$gene), FUN="max")
  SpliceCompare <- merge(SpliceMin, SpliceMax, by = "Group.1")
  colnames(SpliceCompare) <- c("gene", "min", "max")

  # Define diff-spliced genes as those with both elevated and
  # repressed isoforms, when comparing control and pheromone-treated workers
  output <- data.frame(gene = SpliceCompare$gene[SpliceCompare$min < 1 & SpliceCompare$max > 1], stringsAsFactors = F)

  # Add the Apis mellifera ortholog, from one-way BLAST, if it's a non-Apis species
  if(species != "am"){
    orthologs <- tbl(my_db, paste(species, "2am", sep = "")) %>% select(-evalue) %>% collect(n=Inf) %>% as.data.frame()
    names(orthologs) <- c("gene", "Amel_ortholog")
    output <- left_join(output, orthologs, by = "gene")
    output <- left_join(output, tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>%
                          rename(Amel_ortholog = gene), copy=T, by = "Amel_ortholog")
  }
  else output <- left_join(output, tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), by = "gene", copy = T)

  output[is.na(output)] <- " "

  # Remove the 'isoform X' part from the gene name, so it gives the name of the gene not the isoform
  output$name <- unlist(lapply(strsplit(output$name, split = " isoform "), function(x) x[1]))

  output <- left_join(output, SpliceCompare, by = "gene")

  output$min <- log2(output$min) # Log2 transform the fold changes
  output$max <- log2(output$max)
  output <- output %>% arrange(-(abs(min) + max)) # Arrange by effect size

  if(species == "am" | species == "bt") names(output) <- c("Gene", "Name", "Lowest FC", "Highest FC")
  else names(output) <- c("Gene", "Amel ortholog", "Name", "Lowest FC", "Highest FC")
  output
}

am.alt.splice <- find.alternatively.spliced.genes("am")
saveRDS(am.alt.splice, file = "supplement/tab_S11.rds")
kable.table(am.alt.splice)

lf.alt.splice<- find.alternatively.spliced.genes("lf")
saveRDS(lf.alt.splice, file = "supplement/tab_S12.rds")
kable.table(lf.alt.splice)

ln.alt.splice <- find.alternatively.spliced.genes("ln")
saveRDS(ln.alt.splice, file = "supplement/tab_S13.rds")
kable.table(ln.alt.splice)

lf.alt <- lf.alt.splice$Name[lf.alt.splice$Name != " "] # Exclude genes with no A. mellifera names
ln.alt <- ln.alt.splice$Name[ln.alt.splice$Name != " "]
venn(list(Apis = am.alt.splice$Name,`L. flavus` = lf.alt,`L. niger` = ln.alt))

Gene co-expression network analysis

First, we define a series of functions for gene co-expression network analysis.

# This function uses the ComBat function from the package 'sva' to remove variance in gene expression
# that is due to colony and species, allowing us to detect variance due to queen pheromone treatment.
# The use of ComBat in this fashion follows recommendations from the author of the WGCNA package. 
remove.effects.combat <- function(expression.data){
  sampleIDs <- rownames(expression.data)
  ids <- with(treatments[match(sampleIDs, treatments$id), ], 
              data.frame(
                id = sampleIDs,
                species = species,
                treatment = treatment,
                colony = paste(species, colony, sep = "")))
  
  modcombat <- model.matrix(~as.factor(treatment), data=ids)
  shh <- capture.output(expression.data <- ComBat(dat = t(expression.data), 
                                                  batch = ids$species, 
                                                  mod = modcombat, 
                                                  par.prior = TRUE))
  shh <- capture.output(expression.data <- t(ComBat(dat = expression.data, 
                                                    batch = ids$colony, 
                                                    mod = modcombat, 
                                                    par.prior = TRUE)))
  list(expression.data, ids)
}


# Build a gene coexpresison network using WGCNA package
build.network <- function(expression.data.list){
  # Pick the soft thresholding power that gives a model fit of R^2 > 0.8 for the scale-free topology model
  soft.power <- pickSoftThreshold(expression.data.list[[1]], 
                                  RsquaredCut = 0.8, verbose = 0, powerVector = 1:30)
  # Use this power to generate a gene co-expression network, using the default settings
  network <- blockwiseModules(expression.data.list[[1]], 
                              power = soft.power$powerEstimate,
                              networkType = "signed",
                              minModuleSize = 30,
                              verbose = 0,
                              saveTOMs = T)
  list(network, expression.data.list[[2]])
}


# By default, WGCNA gives the transcriptional modules random names like 'turqoise' or 'darkred'. 
# I think it's more helpful to define the biggest module as 'Module 1', the second biggest as 'Module 2', etc
# I use the label 'Module 0' for genes that were not assigned to a module
convert.module.colors.to.names <- function(network){
  module.sizes <- table(network[[1]]$colors) %>% sort %>% rev
  module.sizes <- c(module.sizes[names(module.sizes) == "grey"], 
                    module.sizes[names(module.sizes) != "grey"])
  module.mappings <- data.frame(color = names(module.sizes), 
                                new.name = paste("Module", 
                                                 0:(length(module.sizes)-1)), stringsAsFactors = F)
  network[[1]]$colors <- module.mappings$new.name[match(network[[1]]$colors, module.mappings$color)]
  names(network[[1]]$MEs) <- gsub("ME", "", names(network[[1]]$MEs))
  names(network[[1]]$MEs) <- module.mappings$new.name[match(names(network[[1]]$MEs), 
                                                            module.mappings$color)]
  network
}


# Rearrange the data in a handy format for stats and plotting, and remove the 'Module 0', the un-assigned genes
rearrange.eigengene.data <- function(network.list){
  cbind(network.list[[2]], network.list[[1]]$MEs) %>% 
    gather(Module, Eigengene, starts_with("Module")) %>% 
    filter(Module != "Module 0") %>%
    rename(Species = species, Treatment = treatment) %>% 
    arrange(Species, Treatment, colony, Module)
} 

# The 4 bad samples get removed, then we find the orthologous genes, the data are scaled with ComBat, and then we build the network using the lowest soft-thresholding power that gives at least R^2 > 0.8 model fit
OGGs <- make.OGGs(c("am", "bt", "ln", "lf"), bad.samples = bad.samples)
network <- OGGs[[1]] %>%
  remove.effects.combat() %>% 
  build.network() %>%
  convert.module.colors.to.names()
eigen.data <- network %>% rearrange.eigengene.data

length(network[[1]]$colors)

[1] 3465

table(network[[1]]$colors) %>% pander

# Make a plot of the module eigengenes, split by species, module and treatment
treatments.network.plot <- function(dat){ 
  dat %>% mutate(Treatment = replace(as.character(Treatment), Treatment == "QP", "Queen\npheromone")) %>%
    ggplot(aes(Species, Eigengene, fill = Treatment)) + 
    geom_hline(yintercept = 0, linetype=2) + 
    geom_boxplot() + 
    facet_wrap(~Module) + 
    xlab(NULL) + 
    scale_x_discrete(labels = c("Apis\nmellifera", "Bombus\nterrestris", "Lasius\nflavus", "Lasius\nniger")) +
    scale_fill_brewer(name = " ", palette = "Set3", direction = -1) + 
    theme_bw() + 
    theme(strip.background = element_blank(), 
          axis.text.x = element_text(face = "italic"), 
          panel.border = element_rect(size=0.7), 
          legend.position = "top") 
}

eigen.data %>% treatments.network.plot()

ggsave(eigen.data %>% treatments.network.plot(), 
       file = "figures/Figure 3 - Module eigengenes.pdf", height = 6.6, width = 8)

readRDS("data/brms_model_comparisons.rds") %>% pander()

cat(paste(readLines("data/brms_model.txt"), "\n", sep = ""))

 Family: MV(gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian, gaussian) 
   Links: mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity
          mu = identity; sigma = identity 
 Formula: m1 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m2 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m3 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m4 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m5 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m6 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m7 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m8 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
          m9 ~ Treatment + (1 | p | colony) 
    Data: eigen.data %>% mutate(Module = gsub("Module ", "m" (Number of observations: 39) 
 Samples: 4 chains, each with iter = 5000; warmup = 2500; thin = 1;
          total post-warmup samples = 10000
 
 Group-Level Effects: 
 ~colony (Number of levels: 27) 
                                Estimate Est.Error l-95% CI u-95% CI Eff.Sample Rhat
 sd(m1_Intercept)                   0.08      0.06     0.00     0.21       4356 1.00
 sd(m2_Intercept)                   0.04      0.03     0.00     0.12       7092 1.00
 sd(m3_Intercept)                   0.04      0.03     0.00     0.13      10000 1.00
 sd(m4_Intercept)                   0.04      0.03     0.00     0.13       8519 1.00
 sd(m5_Intercept)                   0.05      0.03     0.00     0.12       4317 1.00
 sd(m6_Intercept)                   0.05      0.04     0.00     0.14       4690 1.00
 sd(m7_Intercept)                   0.06      0.04     0.00     0.17      10000 1.00
 sd(m8_Intercept)                   0.13      0.09     0.01     0.34       6666 1.00
 sd(m9_Intercept)                   0.04      0.03     0.00     0.12       5685 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m2_Intercept)     0.02      0.32    -0.58     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m3_Intercept)     0.01      0.32    -0.60     0.61      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m3_Intercept)    -0.01      0.32    -0.62     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m4_Intercept)    -0.00      0.32    -0.62     0.61      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m4_Intercept)     0.05      0.32    -0.57     0.64      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m4_Intercept)    -0.02      0.32    -0.62     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m5_Intercept)     0.02      0.32    -0.58     0.61      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m5_Intercept)     0.00      0.32    -0.60     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m5_Intercept)    -0.02      0.32    -0.63     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m4_Intercept,m5_Intercept)     0.02      0.32    -0.58     0.62      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m6_Intercept)     0.00      0.31    -0.59     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m6_Intercept)    -0.02      0.32    -0.61     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m6_Intercept)     0.05      0.32    -0.58     0.64      10000 1.00
 cor(m4_Intercept,m6_Intercept)     0.03      0.31    -0.57     0.63      10000 1.00
 cor(m5_Intercept,m6_Intercept)     0.03      0.32    -0.58     0.63      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m7_Intercept)    -0.01      0.32    -0.61     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m7_Intercept)     0.02      0.32    -0.59     0.62      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m7_Intercept)     0.06      0.32    -0.57     0.65      10000 1.00
 cor(m4_Intercept,m7_Intercept)     0.02      0.32    -0.58     0.62      10000 1.00
 cor(m5_Intercept,m7_Intercept)    -0.01      0.32    -0.61     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m6_Intercept,m7_Intercept)    -0.02      0.32    -0.63     0.59      10000 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m8_Intercept)     0.01      0.31    -0.59     0.61      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m8_Intercept)    -0.01      0.31    -0.60     0.58      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m8_Intercept)     0.04      0.32    -0.57     0.64      10000 1.00
 cor(m4_Intercept,m8_Intercept)     0.02      0.31    -0.58     0.61      10000 1.00
 cor(m5_Intercept,m8_Intercept)    -0.00      0.32    -0.60     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m6_Intercept,m8_Intercept)    -0.04      0.31    -0.62     0.57       7970 1.00
 cor(m7_Intercept,m8_Intercept)    -0.04      0.32    -0.62     0.58       6458 1.00
 cor(m1_Intercept,m9_Intercept)    -0.01      0.32    -0.62     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m2_Intercept,m9_Intercept)     0.05      0.33    -0.59     0.65      10000 1.00
 cor(m3_Intercept,m9_Intercept)    -0.00      0.32    -0.61     0.60      10000 1.00
 cor(m4_Intercept,m9_Intercept)    -0.05      0.32    -0.64     0.57      10000 1.00
 cor(m5_Intercept,m9_Intercept)     0.04      0.31    -0.57     0.62      10000 1.00
 cor(m6_Intercept,m9_Intercept)     0.02      0.31    -0.59     0.62       8255 1.00
 cor(m7_Intercept,m9_Intercept)     0.01      0.32    -0.60     0.61       6350 1.00
 cor(m8_Intercept,m9_Intercept)     0.03      0.32    -0.58     0.63       6231 1.00
 
 Population-Level Effects: 
                Estimate Est.Error l-95% CI u-95% CI Eff.Sample Rhat
 m1_Intercept      -0.27      0.18    -0.64     0.09       4403 1.00
 m2_Intercept      -0.23      0.19    -0.60     0.14       5015 1.00
 m3_Intercept       0.23      0.19    -0.16     0.60       5448 1.00
 m4_Intercept      -0.63      0.15    -0.92    -0.32       5864 1.00
 m5_Intercept      -0.18      0.18    -0.53     0.19       4295 1.00
 m6_Intercept       0.03      0.20    -0.36     0.43       5752 1.00
 m7_Intercept      -0.05      0.20    -0.46     0.34       5803 1.00
 m8_Intercept       0.13      0.21    -0.28     0.54       5686 1.00
 m9_Intercept       0.32      0.17    -0.01     0.67       4355 1.00
 m1_TreatmentQP     0.56      0.26     0.04     1.06       4299 1.00
 m2_TreatmentQP     0.48      0.27    -0.06     1.00       4542 1.00
 m3_TreatmentQP    -0.47      0.28    -1.01     0.10       5341 1.00
 m4_TreatmentQP     1.28      0.22     0.85     1.71       5443 1.00
 m5_TreatmentQP     0.37      0.26    -0.15     0.86       4059 1.00
 m6_TreatmentQP    -0.07      0.29    -0.65     0.50       5358 1.00
 m7_TreatmentQP     0.11      0.30    -0.47     0.69       5655 1.00
 m8_TreatmentQP    -0.27      0.29    -0.85     0.32       5407 1.00
 m9_TreatmentQP    -0.66      0.25    -1.16    -0.17       4120 1.00
 
 Family Specific Parameters: 
          Estimate Est.Error l-95% CI u-95% CI Eff.Sample Rhat
 sigma_m1     0.82      0.08     0.69     0.98      10000 1.00
 sigma_m2     0.84      0.08     0.70     1.01       7447 1.00
 sigma_m3     0.87      0.09     0.72     1.05       7227 1.00
 sigma_m4     0.70      0.07     0.58     0.85      10000 1.00
 sigma_m5     0.82      0.07     0.69     0.97       5832 1.00
 sigma_m6     0.90      0.09     0.75     1.10       6538 1.00
 sigma_m7     0.92      0.09     0.76     1.12      10000 1.00
 sigma_m8     0.91      0.10     0.75     1.12      10000 1.00
 sigma_m9     0.79      0.07     0.66     0.94       6247 1.00
 
 Residual Correlations: 
               Estimate Est.Error l-95% CI u-95% CI Eff.Sample Rhat
 rescor(m1,m2)     0.56      0.10     0.35     0.73       6438 1.00
 rescor(m1,m3)     0.69      0.08     0.51     0.82       7120 1.00
 rescor(m2,m3)     0.25      0.12    -0.00     0.48      10000 1.00
 rescor(m1,m4)     0.53      0.10     0.31     0.71       8099 1.00
 rescor(m2,m4)     0.73      0.07     0.56     0.84      10000 1.00
 rescor(m3,m4)     0.10      0.13    -0.17     0.35      10000 1.00
 rescor(m1,m5)     0.59      0.10     0.38     0.76       5667 1.00
 rescor(m2,m5)     0.66      0.08     0.48     0.79       5941 1.00
 rescor(m3,m5)     0.42      0.11     0.19     0.61       8145 1.00
 rescor(m4,m5)     0.71      0.07     0.55     0.83       7301 1.00
 rescor(m1,m6)     0.65      0.09     0.45     0.79       6974 1.00
 rescor(m2,m6)     0.19      0.13    -0.07     0.43      10000 1.00
 rescor(m3,m6)     0.64      0.08     0.46     0.78       8022 1.00
 rescor(m4,m6)     0.32      0.12     0.06     0.54       8027 1.00
 rescor(m5,m6)     0.78      0.06     0.65     0.87      10000 1.00
 rescor(m1,m7)     0.59      0.10     0.36     0.75      10000 1.00
 rescor(m2,m7)     0.59      0.09     0.39     0.74      10000 1.00
 rescor(m3,m7)     0.71      0.07     0.54     0.83      10000 1.00
 rescor(m4,m7)     0.32      0.12     0.06     0.55      10000 1.00
 rescor(m5,m7)     0.35      0.12     0.11     0.56       8081 1.00
 rescor(m6,m7)     0.21      0.13    -0.07     0.45       8440 1.00
 rescor(m1,m8)     0.53      0.11     0.29     0.71      10000 1.00
 rescor(m2,m8)     0.53      0.10     0.30     0.71      10000 1.00
 rescor(m3,m8)     0.55      0.10     0.34     0.72      10000 1.00
 rescor(m4,m8)     0.46      0.11     0.22     0.66      10000 1.00
 rescor(m5,m8)     0.49      0.11     0.26     0.68      10000 1.00
 rescor(m6,m8)     0.39      0.12     0.13     0.60      10000 1.00
 rescor(m7,m8)     0.44      0.12     0.18     0.65      10000 1.00
 rescor(m1,m9)     0.57      0.10     0.35     0.74       5328 1.00
 rescor(m2,m9)     0.77      0.06     0.64     0.87       7273 1.00
 rescor(m3,m9)     0.54      0.10     0.33     0.70      10000 1.00
 rescor(m4,m9)     0.45      0.11     0.21     0.65      10000 1.00
 rescor(m5,m9)     0.83      0.05     0.71     0.90      10000 1.00
 rescor(m6,m9)     0.60      0.09     0.39     0.75      10000 1.00
 rescor(m7,m9)     0.57      0.10     0.35     0.73      10000 1.00
 rescor(m8,m9)     0.52      0.11     0.28     0.70      10000 1.00
 
 Samples were drawn using sampling(NUTS). For each parameter, Eff.Sample 
 is a crude measure of effective sample size, and Rhat is the potential 
 scale reduction factor on split chains (at convergence, Rhat = 1).

meta.module.plot <- function(network){
 
  MET <- network[[1]]$MEs 
  MET <- data.frame(QP = (network[[2]]$treatment %>% as.numeric())-1, MET) %>% dplyr::select(-Module.0)
  names(MET) <- gsub("[.]", " ", names(MET))
  cluster <- (1 - cor(MET)) %>% as.dist() %>% hclust()
  ordering <- cluster$labels[cluster$order]
  heat.map.data <- cor(MET) %>% melt %>% 
    mutate(Var1 = factor(Var1, levels = ordering),
           Var2 = factor(Var2, levels = ordering)) %>% 
    rename(Corr = value)
  heat.map <- heat.map.data %>% ggplot(aes(Var1, Var2, fill = Corr)) + geom_tile() + 
    scale_fill_gradient2(low = brewer.pal(9, "RdBu")[8], 
                         mid = "white", 
                         high = brewer.pal(9, "RdBu")[2]) + 
    xlab(NULL) + ylab(NULL) + 
    theme_bw() + 
    theme(panel.border = element_blank(), 
          panel.grid = element_blank()) + 
    scale_x_discrete(expand = c(0,0)) + 
    scale_y_discrete(expand = c(0,0))
 
  dendrogram <- ggdendrogram(cluster) + theme(axis.text.x = element_blank(), axis.text.y = element_blank())
  
  p1 <- grid.arrange(dendrogram, heat.map)
  invisible(p1)
}

meta.module.plot(network)

load("blockwiseTOM-block.1.RData") # Load the TOM from the network analysis - can be used to find connectedness for each ortholog

# Get the phermonone sensitivity value for each of the OGGs, and line it up with the connectedness data
suppressMessages(dd <- OGGs[[2]] %>% left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% select(gene, PostFC) %>% rename(am=gene), copy=T) %>% rename(am_FC = PostFC) %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_bt") %>% select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
              rename(bt=gene), copy=T) %>% rename(bt_FC = PostFC) %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
              rename(lf=gene), copy=T) %>% rename(lf_FC = PostFC) %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% select(gene, PostFC) %>% 
              rename(ln=gene), copy=T) %>% rename(ln_FC = PostFC) %>%
  mutate(k = colSums(as.matrix(TOM))))

do.spearman <- function(dd, species, name){ # run spearman on each species
  test <- cor.test(dd$k, dd[, names(dd) == species] %>% log2 %>% abs, method = "spearman")  # Note that we convert the fold-change in expression with abs(log2(x)), to get pheromone sensitivity
  with(test, data.frame(Species = name, rho = estimate, p = p.value, row.names = NULL))
}

suppressWarnings(results <- rbind(do.spearman(dd, "am_FC", "Apis mellifera"),
                                  do.spearman(dd, "bt_FC", "Bombus terrestris"),
                                  do.spearman(dd, "lf_FC", "Lasius flavus"),
                                  do.spearman(dd, "ln_FC", "Lasius niger")))
rownames(results) <- NULL
saveRDS(results, file = "supplement/tab_S16.rds")
pander(results)

Characteristics of pheromone-sensitive genes in Apis

In this section, we search for correlates of the absolute Log_2 fold change in response to pheromone (where positive values denote genes whose expression differs strongly between the control and pheromone treatment). This section makes use of data kindly passed to us by Soojin Yi and Brendan Hunt.

1. The data on queen and worker-specific gene expression come from Grozinger et al. 2007. We found that pheromone-sensitive genes tend to be over-expressed by queens relative to sterile workers. However, genes that are over-expressed by fertile workers relative to sterile workers did not tend to be more (or less) pheromone-sensitive.

2. The methylation level (i.e. % methylated cytosines) data come from Galbraith et al. 2016 (provided by Soojin Yi). We found a negative correlation between methylation and pheromone-sensitivity, suggesting that pheromone-sensitive genes are hypomethylated.

3. The CpG O/E values were calculated by Yi and colleagues for the latest A. mellifera genome annotation (as of late 2017). We found a positive correlation between CpG O/E and pheromone-sensitivity. High CpG is associated with lower rate of DNA methylation, again suggesting that pheromone-sensitive genes are hypomethylated.

4. The columns on the H3K4me3, H3K27ac, and H3K36me3 histon modifications were calculated from the raw data from Wojciechowski et al. 2018, using the code in the separate R script wojciechowski_histone_analysis.R.

5. The estimates of \(\gamma\), a measure of positive and negative selection similar to dN/dS, come from Harpur et al. 2014 PNAS. There was a significant positive correlation between \(\gamma\) and sensitivity to queen pheromone, suggesting that highly pheromone-sensitive genes tend to be positively selected.

6. The codon adaptation index was provided by Brendan Hunt. A high codon adaptation index denotes high codon usage bias, meaning that certain synonymous codons are more common than others. Pheromone-sensitive genes showed low codon usage bias.

7. Lastly, ‘expression level’ refers to the average expression of each gene, expressed as TPM (transcripts per million) as measured by the software RSEM in the present study. Highly expressed genes tended to be less pheromone-sensitive.

# import and clean up the data provided by Brendan Hunt
hunt.data <- read.delim("data/apis_gene_comparisons/Amel_AllData_012709.txt", 
                        header=T, stringsAsFactors = FALSE) %>% 
  mutate(log2RW.SW = log2(RW_bagel / SW_bagel))        # calculate log fold difference in gene expression between fertile and sterile workers
entrez.tbl <- read.delim("data/apis_gene_comparisons/am.gene_info.txt", stringsAsFactors = FALSE)[,c(2,5,6)] # import table of gene names (Entrez, old Beebase, and new Beebase)
names(entrez.tbl) <- c("entrez.id", "beebase1", "beebase2")
entrez.tbl <- entrez.tbl %>% mutate(beebase2 = gsub("BEEBASE:", "", beebase2))
entrez.tbl$beebase2[entrez.tbl$beebase2 == "-"] <- entrez.tbl$beebase1[entrez.tbl$beebase2 == "-"]
entrez.tbl$beebase2[grep("\\|", entrez.tbl$beebase2)] <- unname(unlist(sapply(entrez.tbl$beebase2[grep("\\|", entrez.tbl$beebase2)], function(x){
  namess <- strsplit(x, split = "\\|")[[1]]
  hits <-str_detect(namess, "GB")
  if(sum(hits) == 0) return(NA)
  return(namess[hits])
})))

hunt.data <- hunt.data %>% 
  dplyr::select(ID, log2Q.SW, log2RW.SW, CAI, cpgOE) %>% # get gene ID and the relevant data
  rename(beebase1 = ID) %>%                              # merge based on beebase IDs
  left_join(entrez.tbl, by = "beebase1") %>% 
  filter(!is.na(beebase2) & beebase2 != "-") %>% 
  rename(gene = beebase2) %>% 
  dplyr::select(gene, log2Q.SW, log2RW.SW, CAI, cpgOE)
hunt.data <- left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>%       # merge Hunt's data with our phermone sensitivity data
                         dplyr::select(gene, PostFC) %>% collect(), hunt.data, by = "gene") %>% 
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>% collect, by = "gene")  # also add the gene names 

# Import methylation data provided by Soojin Yi and Xin Wu (teh data are from Galbraith et al PNAS)
methylation <- read.csv("data/apis_gene_comparisons/apis_gene_methyl_CG_OE.csv", stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
methylation <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% collect %>% left_join(methylation, by = "gene") %>%
  filter(!is.na(Gene_body_methylation)) %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names") %>% collect(), by = "gene") %>% distinct(gene, .keep_all = T)

# Import gamma data from Harpur et al 2014 PNAS
gamma_am <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% collect() %>%
  left_join(read.table("data/apis_gene_comparisons/harpur_etal_gamma.txt", header=TRUE, stringsAsFactors=FALSE) %>% rename(gene = Gene), by = "gene") %>%
  filter(!is.na(gamma)) %>%
  dplyr::select(gene, PostFC, gamma) %>%
  mutate(PostFC = log2(PostFC)) %>% left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), copy=TRUE, by = "gene") %>%
  arrange(-abs(PostFC))


merged <- hunt.data %>% dplyr::select(gene, PostFC, log2Q.SW, log2RW.SW, CAI) %>% 
  left_join(methylation %>% dplyr::select(gene, CG_OE, Gene_body_methylation), by = "gene") %>% # merge in methylation data provided by Soojin Yi
  left_join(gamma_am %>% dplyr::select(gene, gamma), by = "gene") %>%                         # merge in gamma data from Harpur et al
  left_join(data.frame(gene = tbl(my_db, "rsem_am") %>% 
                         dplyr::select(gene) %>% collect(),  # calculate overall expression level from our own data
                       expression.level = (tbl(my_db, "rsem_am") %>% 
                                             dplyr::select(-gene) %>% 
                                             collect %>% rowSums())), by = "gene") %>% 
  left_join(dd %>% dplyr::select(am, k) %>% rename(gene=am), by = "gene") %>%
  mutate(CG_OE = -log2(CG_OE),                         # log2 CpG O/E ratio - change the sign, so that high values mean high methylation
         expression.level = log10(expression.level),   # log10 the expression level
         PostFC = abs(log2(PostFC))) %>%               # absolute log2 fold-change in response to pheromones (i.e. 'pheromone sensitivity' score)
  as.data.frame() #%>%
  # dplyr::select(-gene) 

# Add the data from Wojciechowski et al. 2018 Genome Biology
# There is gene-level data on the caste difference in 3 different histone modifications (from ChIP-seq),
# These data were created from Wojciechowski et al.'s raw data, as described in the separate R script wojciechowski_histone_analysis.R
merged <- merged %>% 
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "H3K4me3") %>% collect() %>% mutate(H3K4me3_caste = caste_difference) %>% select(gene, H3K4me3_caste), by = "gene") %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "H3K27ac") %>% collect() %>% mutate(H3K27ac_caste = caste_difference) %>% select(gene, H3K27ac_caste), by = "gene") %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "H3K36me3") %>% collect() %>% mutate(H3K36me3_caste = caste_difference) %>% select(gene, H3K36me3_caste), by = "gene") %>%
  dplyr::select(-gene) 
  

m.rename <- function(merged, col, new) {names(merged)[names(merged) == col] <- new; merged}
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("PostFC", "Pheromone sensitivity\n(absolute log fold)")   # re-label all the variables nicely
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("log2Q.SW", "Upregulation in adult queens\nover sterile workers (log fold)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("log2RW.SW", "Upregulation in fertile workers\nover sterile workers (log fold)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("CAI", "Codon usage bias\n(CAI)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("CG_OE", "DNA methylation frequency\n(CpG depletion)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("Gene_body_methylation", "DNA methylation frequency\n(BiS-seq)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("gamma", "Positive selection\n(Gamma)")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("expression.level", "Log Expression level")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("k", "Connectivity in the\ntranscriptome")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("H3K4me3_caste", "Caste difference in\nH3K4me3 modification")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("H3K27ac_caste", "Caste difference in\nH3K27ac modification")
merged <- merged %>% m.rename("H3K36me3_caste", "Caste difference in\nH3K36me3 modification")

entrez.tbl <- entrez.tbl %>% rename(gene = beebase2) %>% select(gene, entrez.id)

# function to reorder a correlation matrix using hierarchical clustering
reorder_cormat <- function(cormat){ 
  dd <- as.dist((1-cormat)/2)
  hc <- hclust(dd)
  cormat[hc$order, hc$order]}

cormat <- reorder_cormat(cor(merged, use = 'pairwise.complete.obs', method = "spearman"))
cormat[upper.tri(cormat)] <- NA
diag(cormat) <- NA

cor.matrix <-  (melt(cormat) %>% filter(!is.na(value)))[,1:2] %>% mutate(cor=0,p=0) 
for(i in 1:nrow(cor.matrix)) cor.matrix[i, 3:4] <- cor.test(merged[, names(merged) == cor.matrix$Var1[i]], merged[, names(merged) == cor.matrix$Var2[i]])[c(4,3)] %>% unlist
cor.matrix$p <- p.adjust(cor.matrix$p, method = "BH") # apply B-H p value correction
cor.matrix$sig <- ""
cor.matrix$sig[cor.matrix$p < 0.05] <- "*"   
cor.matrix$sig[cor.matrix$p < 0.001] <- "**"  
cor.matrix$sig[cor.matrix$p < 0.0001] <- "***"   
cor.matrix$label <- paste(format(round(cor.matrix$cor,2), nSmall =2), cor.matrix$sig, sep = "")
correlation.plot <- cor.matrix %>% 
  ggplot(aes(Var1, Var2, fill=cor)) + 
  geom_tile(colour = "grey10", size = 0.4, linetype = 3) + 
  scale_fill_distiller(palette = "RdYlBu") + 
  geom_text(aes(label = label), colour = "grey25", size = 3.5) + 
  xlab(NULL) + ylab(NULL) +
  scale_x_discrete(expand=c(0.01,0.01)) + scale_y_discrete(expand = c(0.01, 0.01)) + 
  theme_minimal() + theme(axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 45, hjust = 1, 
                                                     face = c("plain", "bold", rep("plain", 5), "bold",  rep("plain", 4))), 
                          axis.text.y = element_text(face = c("bold", "plain", "bold", rep("plain", 5), "bold",  "plain", "plain")), 
                          panel.grid = element_blank(), 
                          legend.position = "none") 
ggsave(correlation.plot, file = "figures/Figure 5 - correlations.pdf", width = 8, height = 8)
correlation.plot

Past versions of unnamed-chunk-24-1.png

Figure 5: Spearman correlations for various gene-level measurements from the present study and earlier research, for Apis mellifera (measurements from the present study are shown in bold). ‘Pheromone sensitivity’ was calculated as the absolute value of the Log\(_2\) fold difference in expression between pheromone treatment and the control. Expression level shows the logarithm of the average across our 6 Apis libraries. For the ‘Upregulation in queens/fertile workers’ data (Grozinger et al. 2007), positive values denote genes that have higher expression in queens or fertile workers, relative to sterile workers. For the three histone modification variables (Wojciechowski et al. 2018), high values indicate that the modification is more abundant in queen-destined larvae, and low values indicate it is more abundant in worker-destined larvae. The two DNA methylation variables give two different measures of the amount of gene body DNA methylation, namely an indirect measure (-log CpG O/E ratio) and a direct measure (BiS-seq, Galbraith et al. 2016). Codon usage bias was estimated using the codon adaptation index: high values indicate bias for particular synonymous codons. Lastly, the parameter gamma (\(\gamma\)) describes the form of selection, where positive values denote positive selection, and negative values purifying selection (data from Hunt et al. 2014).

Contrasting our Lasius data with results from Morandin et al. 2016

Morandin et al. 2016 (Genome Biology 17:43) studied whole transcriptomes from queens and workers in 16 diverse ant species, including two other species from the genus Lasius. Using BLAST, they grouped genes into OGGs (orthologous gene groups), and built a co-expression network using all the OGGs that were common to all 16 species via the software WGCNA (much like the present study). Their analysis yielded 36 modules, of which many showed significant queen-worker differences in their module eigengenes. Here, we want to test whether these queen- and worker-like modules significantly overlap with the pheromone-sensitive modules in the present study.

To do this, we used BLAST to identify orthologous gens in L. niger and L. flavus that belong to one of Morandin et al.’s OGGs. We then tested for significantly-greater-than-random overlap between Morandin et al’s modules, and our own study’s modules, using hypergeometric tests.

Of all the possible module pairs, we found 6 pairs that overlapped significantly more than expected (FDR-corrected). One of these pairs included our highly pheromone-sensitive module, Module 4, which overlapped with the caste-biased Module 13 from Morandin et al. The intersecting genes include protein take-out like, a NAD kinase 2, a serine protease, and histone H2A-like.

morandin.orthology <- read.csv("data/morandin_comparison_data/Morandin to Holman orthology.csv", stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
morandin.module.membership <- read.csv("data/morandin_comparison_data/Morandin module membership.csv", stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
morandin.module.caste.bias <- read.csv("data/morandin_comparison_data/Morandin module caste bias.csv", stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
# Create list of all the L. niger & L. flavus genes are are part of
# the Orthologous Gene Groups (OGGs) from Morandin et al.
# Here are the 3634 genes for which we have 1-to-1 orthologs in all 18 species:
morandin.oggs <- make.OGGs(c("ln", "lf"))[[2]] %>% 
  left_join(morandin.orthology, by = "ln") %>%
  filter(!is.na(morandin.ogg)) %>% 
  left_join(morandin.module.membership, by = "morandin.ogg") %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "ln2am") %>% 
              left_join(tbl(my_db, "bee_names"), by = c("am" = "gene")) %>%
              filter(!is.na(name)) %>% select(ln, name, am) %>% 
              rename(apis.name = name) %>% collect(n=Inf), by = "ln") %>%
  left_join(morandin.module.caste.bias, by = "module") %>%
  rename(morandin.module = module) %>%
  left_join(data.frame(ln = OGGs[[2]]$ln, 
                       holman.module = network[[1]]$colors, 
                       stringsAsFactors = F), by = "ln") %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% 
              select(gene, PostFC) %>% collect(n=Inf) %>% rename(ln = gene), by = "ln") %>%
  rename(FC.pheromone = PostFC)
overlaps <- table(morandin.oggs$morandin.module, 
                  morandin.oggs$holman.module) %>% 
  melt() %>% rename(morandin.module = Var1, 
                    holman.module = Var2, 
                    overlaps = value) %>%
  filter(holman.module != "Module 0") %>%
  left_join(table(morandin.oggs$morandin.module) %>% 
              melt() %>% rename(mor.mod.size = value), 
            by = c("morandin.module" = "Var1")) %>% 
  left_join(table(morandin.oggs$holman.module) %>% melt() %>% 
              rename(hol.mod.size = value), by = c("holman.module" = "Var1"))

# List all the Morandin et al. modules that significantly overlap with our own modules
overlaps <- data.frame(
  overlaps, 
  do.call("rbind", 
          lapply(1:nrow(overlaps), 
                 function(i) with(overlaps, 
                                  overlap.hypergeometric.test(
                                    overlaps[i], 
                                    mor.mod.size[i], 
                                    hol.mod.size[i], 
                                    nrow(morandin.oggs), 
                                    species = "xx"))))[,2:3]) %>% 
  filter(Test == "Overlap is higher than expected:") %>% 
  arrange(p) %>% select(-Test) %>% 
  left_join(morandin.oggs %>% 
              select(morandin.module, caste.bias) %>% 
              distinct(), by = "morandin.module") %>% 
  mutate(p = p.adjust(p, method = "BH"),
         morandin.module = paste("Module", morandin.module)) %>%
  filter(p < 0.05) 
names(overlaps) <- c("Morandin module", "Holman module", "n overlapping genes", "Size of Morandin module", "Size of Holman module", "p-value", "Caste bias of Morandin module")

Table S17: A list of the six module pairs, from Morandin et al. 2016 and the present study, which had significantly more genes in common than expected by chance. The p-values were calculated by running hypergeometric tests on all possible pairs of modules from the two studies, and then adjusting all the p-values using the Benjamini-Hochberg procedure.

saveRDS(overlaps, file = "supplement/tab_S17.rds")
overlaps %>% pander(split.cell = 40, split.table = Inf)

A list of the genes (OGGs) that appear in the present study’s Module 1 (which is pheromone-sensitive), and also in Morandin et al.’s Module 31 (which is caste-biased).

morandin.oggs %>% 
  filter(morandin.module == 31, holman.module == "Module 1") %>% 
  select(am, apis.name) %>% rename(`Apis ortholog ID` = am, `Apis ortholog name` = apis.name) %>% 
  kable.table()

A list of the genes (OGGs) that appear in the present study’s Module 4 (which is pheromone-sensitive), and also in Morandin et al.’s Module 13 (which is caste-biased).

morandin.oggs %>% 
  filter(morandin.module == 13, holman.module == "Module 4") %>% 
  select(am, apis.name) %>% rename(`Apis ortholog ID` = am, `Apis ortholog name` = apis.name) %>% 
  pander(split.cell = 40, split.table = Inf)

GO and KEGG enrichment for differentially expressed genes

First, define some functions we will need. See also the R script Script to set up for GO analyses.R, which was used to get the GO and KEGG data for Apis.

library(GO.db)
library(AnnotationHub)
select <- dplyr::select
rename <- dplyr::rename
filter <- dplyr::filter

if(!file.exists("data/component spreadsheets of queen_pheromone.db/all_apis_go_terms.rds")){
  library(AnnotationHub)
  # Connect to AnnotationHub, and get the annotations for A mellifera
  hub <- AnnotationHub::AnnotationHub()
 
  apis.db <- hub[["AH62534"]]
  apis_go_table <- dbconn(apis.db) %>% tbl("go") %>% collect() # Connect to GO table in the database
  
  apis_go <- tbl(dbconn(apis.db), "go") %>% left_join(tbl(dbconn(apis.db), "entrez_genes")) %>%
    select(ENTREZID, GO, ONTOLOGY) %>%
    rename(gene = ENTREZID, ontology = ONTOLOGY) %>% collect(n = Inf)
  
  apis_entrez_names <- tbl(dbconn(apis.db), "gene_info") %>% left_join(tbl(dbconn(apis.db), "entrez_genes")) %>%
    select(ENTREZID, GENENAME) %>%
    rename(entrez = ENTREZID, name = GENENAME) %>% collect(n = Inf)
  
  go_meanings <- dbconn(GO.db) %>% tbl("go_term") %>% select(go_id, term, ontology) %>% collect()
  
  saveRDS(apis.go, file = "data/component spreadsheets of queen_pheromone.db/all_apis_go_terms.rds")
  saveRDS(go_meanings, file = "data/component spreadsheets of queen_pheromone.db/go_meanings.rds")
  
  my_db$con %>% db_drop_table(table = "apis_go")
  copy_to(my_db, apis_go, "apis_go", temporary = FALSE)
  
  my_db$con %>% db_drop_table(table = "apis_entrez_names")
  copy_to(my_db, apis_entrez_names, "apis_entrez_names", temporary = FALSE)
  
  my_db$con %>% db_drop_table(table = "go_meanings")
  copy_to(my_db, go_meanings, "go_meanings", temporary = FALSE)
}

# Makes a database shortcut (lazy query) to a table of parent and child GO term relationships, from the massive GO.db database
make_db_shortcut <- function(tabl){
  dbconn(GO.db) %>% tbl("go_bp_offspring") %>%
    left_join(dbconn(GO.db) %>% tbl("go_term") %>% select(`_id`, go_id), by = "_id") %>% rename(parent_GO = go_id) %>%
    left_join(dbconn(GO.db) %>% tbl("go_term") %>% select(`_id`, go_id), by = c("_offspring_id" = "_id")) %>%
    rename(child_GO = go_id) %>% select(parent_GO, child_GO)
}

# Function to get all the descendants of a focal GO term, given its "hierarchy" (i.e. one of the lazy db queries BP, MF, or CC)
get_descendants <- function(ancestor, hierarchy) hierarchy %>% filter(parent_GO == ancestor) %>% select(child_GO) %>% collect() %>% .$child_GO

# Fucntion to run GSEA implemented in the fgsea package
GO.and.KEGG.gsea <- function(tabl = NULL, df = NULL, min.size = 5, keep.all = FALSE){
  
  p <- 0.05; if(keep.all) p <- 1 # Set the significance threshold
  
  if(!is.null(tabl)){
    # First, grab the data for the focal species. If not Apis, then get the names of the Apis orthologs via reciprocal best BLAST
    if(tabl == "ebseq_gene_am") {df <- tbl(my_db, tabl) %>% collect()}
    if(tabl == "ebseq_gene_bt") {
      df <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_bt") %>% collect() %>%
        left_join(make.OGGs(c("am", "bt"))[[2]], by = c("gene" = "bt")) %>%
        dplyr::select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
    }
    if(tabl == "ebseq_gene_lf") {
      df <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% collect() %>%
        left_join(make.OGGs(c("am", "lf"))[[2]], by = c("gene" = "lf")) %>%
        select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
    }
    if(tabl == "ebseq_gene_ln") {
      df <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% collect() %>%
        left_join(make.OGGs(c("am", "ln"))[[2]], by = c("gene" = "ln")) %>%
        select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
    }
    # Calculate pheromone sensitivity for each gene
    df <- df %>% mutate(sensitivity = abs(log2(PostFC)) ) %>% arrange(-sensitivity) %>% as.data.frame() 
  }
  
  # Set up the geneList object in the form needed by the fgsea function - named, ranked vector of pheromone sensitivity per gene
  geneList <- df$sensitivity
  names(geneList) <- entrez.tbl$entrez.id[match(df$gene, entrez.tbl$gene)] # Convert Beebase2 to Entrez gene names
  gene_universe <- names(geneList)
  
  # Internal function to run GO enrichment
  GO.enrichment <- function(geneList, ontol){
    
    pathways <- tbl(my_db, "apis_go") %>% 
      filter(gene %in% gene_universe, 
             ontology == ontol) %>% 
      select(-ontology) %>% collect(n=Inf) 
    pathways <- with(pathways, split(gene, GO))
    result <- fgsea::fgsea(pathways, geneList, nperm = 10000, minSize = min.size, maxSize = 500) %>% 
      filter(pval <= p) 
    
    collapse_pathways <- fgsea::collapsePathways(result, pathways, geneList)
    pathways_to_keep <- c(collapse_pathways[[1]], names(collapse_pathways[[2]]))
    result <- result %>% filter(pathway %in% pathways_to_keep)
    
    result <- result %>% 
      rename(ID = pathway) %>% 
      left_join(tbl(my_db, "go_meanings") %>% 
                  select(-ontology) %>% collect(n=Inf), by = c("ID" = "go_id")) 
    
    if(nrow(result) == 0) return(NULL)
    if(ontol == "BP") Test_type <- "GO: Biological process"
    if(ontol == "MF") Test_type <- "GO: Molecular function"
    if(ontol == "CC") Test_type <- "GO: Cellular component"
    data.frame(Test_type = Test_type, result, stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
  }
  
  # Internal function to run KEGG enrichment
  kegg.enrichment <- function(geneList){
    apis_kegg <- clusterProfiler::download_KEGG("ame")
    apis_kegg_names <- apis_kegg[[2]]
    apis_kegg_focal <- apis_kegg[[1]] %>% filter(to %in% gene_universe)
    pathways <- with(apis_kegg_focal, split(to, from))
    result <- fgsea::fgsea(pathways, geneList, nperm = 10000, minSize = min.size, maxSize = 500) %>% 
      filter(pval <= p) 
    collapse_pathways <- fgsea::collapsePathways(result, pathways, geneList)
    
    result <- result %>% filter(pathway %in% c(collapse_pathways[[1]], names(collapse_pathways[[2]]))) %>% 
      rename(ID = pathway) %>% 
      left_join(apis_kegg_names %>% rename(term = to), by = c("ID" = "from")) %>%
      mutate(ID = str_replace_all(ID, "ame", "KEGG:"))
    
    if(nrow(result) == 0) return(NULL)
    data.frame(Test_type = "KEGG", result, stringsAsFactors = FALSE) 
  }
  
  rbind(GO.enrichment(geneList, "BP"),
        GO.enrichment(geneList, "MF"),
        GO.enrichment(geneList, "CC"),
        kegg.enrichment(geneList))  
}

# The previous function has a call to collapse_pathways(), which is great for finding over-arching patterns, but it results in a patchy version of Figure 2. This is because the pathways get collapsed slightly differently in each species, based on which genes happen to have detectable orthologs in A. mellifera, plus the gene expression data itself. This function attempts to fill all the holes in Figure 2 by running additional GSEA tests on all the GO terms that are missing from the figure. A small number of holes remain in Figure 2 due to missing orthologs in the non-Apis species, but mostly it does a good job.
test_child_pathways <- function(row, job_list, three_hierarchies, ebseq_tables, apis_go, go_meanings, three_OGGs, entrez.tbl){ # input: a dataframe of jobs, and the row of the job that needs doing
  
  # Get the focal GO_id, ontology, species, and GO tree
  go_id <- job_list$GO[row]
  ontol <- job_list$Test_type[row]
  Species <- job_list$Species[row]
  if(grepl("Biological", ontol)) {hierarchy <- three_hierarchies[[1]]; short_ontol <- "BP"}
  if(grepl("Molecular", ontol))  {hierarchy <- three_hierarchies[[2]]; short_ontol <- "MF"}
  if(grepl("Cellular", ontol))   {hierarchy <- three_hierarchies[[3]]; short_ontol <- "CC"}
  
  # Get the relevant data needed to rank the genes and make the 'geneList' object
  if(Species == "am") df <- ebseq_tables[[1]]
  if(Species == "bt") {
    df <- ebseq_tables[[2]] %>%
      left_join(three_OGGs[[1]], by = c("gene" = "bt")) %>%
      dplyr::select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
  }
  if(Species == "lf") {
    df <- ebseq_tables[[3]] %>%
      left_join(three_OGGs[[2]], by = c("gene" = "lf")) %>%
      dplyr::select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
  }
  if(Species == "ln") {
    df <- ebseq_tables[[4]] %>%
      left_join(three_OGGs[[3]], by = c("gene" = "ln")) %>%
      dplyr::select(-gene) %>% rename(gene = am) %>% filter(!is.na(gene))
  }
  
  # Set up the geneList object in the form needed by the fgsea function - named, ranked vector of pheromone sensitivity per gene
  df <- df %>% mutate(sensitivity = abs(log2(PostFC))) %>% arrange(-sensitivity) %>% as.data.frame() 
  geneList <- df$sensitivity
  names(geneList) <- entrez.tbl$entrez.id[match(df$gene, entrez.tbl$gene)] # Convert Beebase2 to Entrez gene names
  gene_universe <- names(geneList)
  
  # Run the GSEA, just on the focal GO term (and its descendants)
  pathways <- apis_go %>% filter(gene %in% gene_universe, 
                                 ontology == short_ontol) %>% select(-ontology) 
  
  pathways$GO[pathways$GO %in% get_descendants(go_id, hierarchy)] <- go_id
  pathways <- with(pathways, split(gene, GO))
  foc <- which(names(pathways) == go_id)
  result <- fgsea::fgsea(pathways[foc], geneList, nperm = 10000)
  
  if(nrow(result) > 0) {
    result <- rename(result, ID = pathway) %>% 
      left_join(go_meanings %>% select(-ontology), by = c("ID" = "go_id")) 
    
    return(data.frame(Test_type = ontol, result, Species, stringsAsFactors = FALSE))
  }
  else return(NULL)
}

# Function that attempts to fill in the gaps using test_child_pathways()
fill_in_GSEA_results <- function(GSEA_results){
  # Remove all KEGG and GO terms except those that are significant in at least one species
  results <- GSEA_results %>%
    filter(!is.nan(NES)) %>%
    filter(ID %in% (GSEA_results %>% filter(pval < 0.05) %>% .$ID %>% unique))
  
  # List GO terms that were not measured in all 4 species (often because of the GO concatenation step above)
  incomplete_GOs <- results %>% 
    filter(Test_type != "KEGG") %>% 
    group_by(Test_type, ID) %>% summarise(n = n()) %>% filter(!(n %in% c(4, 8, 12))) %>% .$ID
  
  job_list <- expand.grid(Species = c("am", "bt", "lf", "ln"),
                          GO = incomplete_GOs) %>%
    filter(!(paste(Species, GO) %in% paste(results$Species, results$GO))) %>%
    left_join(results %>% rename(GO = ID) %>% select(GO, Test_type) %>% distinct(), by = "GO")
  
  # Remove combinations that were already run from the job_list
  job_list <- job_list %>% filter(!(paste(Species, GO) %in% paste(GSEA_results$Species, GSEA_results$ID)))
  
  # Pull all of this information into memory, so that we can use mclapply for speed 
  # (mclapply does not play well with database connections)
  three_hierarchies <- list(
    make_db_shortcut("go_bp_offspring") %>% collect(),
    make_db_shortcut("go_mf_offspring") %>% collect(),
    make_db_shortcut("go_cc_offspring") %>% collect()
  )
  
  ebseq_tables <- list(
    tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_am") %>% collect(),
    tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_bt") %>% collect(),
    tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_lf") %>% collect(),
    tbl(my_db, "ebseq_gene_ln") %>% collect()
  )
  apis_go <- tbl(my_db, "apis_go") %>% collect()
  go_meanings <- tbl(my_db, "go_meanings") %>% collect()
  
  three_OGGs <- list(
    make.OGGs(c("am", "bt"))[[2]],
    make.OGGs(c("am", "lf"))[[2]],
    make.OGGs(c("am", "ln"))[[2]]
  )
  
  rbind(results, 
        lapply(1:nrow(job_list), function(i) 
          test_child_pathways(i, job_list, three_hierarchies, ebseq_tables, apis_go, go_meanings, three_OGGs, entrez.tbl)) %>% do.call("rbind", .)) %>%
    distinct() %>%
    rename(Description = term, pvalue = pval, p.adjust = padj) %>%
    filter(!is.nan(NES)) %>%
    mutate(p.adjust = p.adjust(pvalue, method = "BH")) %>%
    arrange(Test_type, Species, pvalue) %>% ungroup()
}


# Run the GO and KEGG enrichment analyses using GSEA implemented in fgsea 
# The functions here run GSEA on each species and all 4 ontologies, 
# then collapse redundant, smaller GO terms into higher-order ones, and then fill in any gaps to make Figure 2 less patchy
set.seed(1)
GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA <- rbind(
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea("ebseq_gene_am", keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "am"),
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea("ebseq_gene_bt", keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "bt"), 
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea("ebseq_gene_lf", keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "lf"), 
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea("ebseq_gene_ln", keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "ln")) %>%
  fill_in_GSEA_results() 

make_enrichment_heatmap <- function(GO_and_KEGG_results, pval_cutoff){
  plot_data <- GO_and_KEGG_results %>% 
    mutate(sig = " ",
           sig = replace(sig, pvalue < 0.05, "*"),
           sig = replace(sig, p.adjust < 0.05, "**")) 
  
  levels <- plot_data %>% 
    group_by(Test_type, Description) %>%
    summarise(summed_NES = sum(NES), n = n()) %>%
    arrange(desc(Test_type), summed_NES) %>% .$Description
  
  
  grid_arrange_shared_legend <- function(p1, p2) {
    plots <- list(p1, p2)
    g <- ggplotGrob(plots[[1]] + theme(legend.position="right"))$grobs
    legend <- g[[which(sapply(g, function(x) x$name) == "guide-box")]]
    lwidth <- sum(legend$width)
    arrangeGrob(
      arrangeGrob(p1 + theme(legend.position="none"), 
                  p2 + theme(legend.position="none"), ncol = 2, widths = c(0.56,0.44)),
      legend,
      ncol = 2,
      widths = unit.c(unit(1, "npc") - lwidth, lwidth))
  }

  output <- grid_arrange_shared_legend(
    plot_data %>% mutate(Description = factor(Description, levels)) %>%
      filter(Test_type %in% c("GO: Biological process", "GO: Molecular function")) %>%
      ggplot(aes(Species, Description, fill = NES)) +
      geom_tile(colour = "grey10", size = 0.4, linetype = 3) + 
      geom_text(aes(label = sig)) +
      scale_fill_distiller(palette = "RdYlBu") + 
      scale_y_discrete(labels = function(x) str_wrap(x, width = 55), expand = c(0,0)) +
      scale_x_discrete(expand = c(0,0)) +
      facet_grid(rows = vars(Test_type), scales = "free_y", space = "free_y") + 
      theme_minimal() +
      theme(panel.border = element_rect(size = 0.8, colour = "grey10", fill = NA),
            strip.text = element_text(size = 10)) + 
      guides(fill = guide_colourbar(frame.colour = "grey10", ticks.colour = "grey10")) + 
      ylab(NULL) + xlab(NULL), 
    plot_data %>% mutate(Description = factor(Description, levels)) %>%
      filter(Test_type %in% c("GO: Cellular component", "KEGG")) %>%
      ggplot(aes(Species, Description, fill = NES)) +
      geom_tile(colour = "grey10", size = 0.4, linetype = 3) + 
      geom_text(aes(label = sig)) +
      scale_fill_distiller(palette = "RdYlBu") + 
      scale_y_discrete(labels = function(x) str_wrap(x, width = 30), expand = c(0,0)) +
      scale_x_discrete(expand = c(0,0)) +
      facet_grid(rows = vars(Test_type), scales = "free_y", space = "free_y") + 
      theme_minimal() +
      theme(panel.border = element_rect(size = 0.8, colour = "grey10", fill = NA),
            strip.text = element_text(size = 10)) + 
      guides(fill = guide_colourbar(frame.colour = "grey10", ticks.colour = "grey10")) + 
      ylab(NULL) + xlab(NULL))  
  
  grobTree(rectGrob(gp = gpar(fill="white", lwd = 0)), output)
}

figure2 <- make_enrichment_heatmap(GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA, pval_cutoff = 0.05)
ggsave(figure2, file = "figures/Figure 2 - GO and KEGG.pdf", height = 11.8, width = 9.5)
grid.draw(figure2)

add_name_col <- function(df){
  sapply(df$leadingEdge, function(x){
      data.frame(gene = x, stringsAsFactors = FALSE) %>%
        left_join(tbl(my_db, "apis_entrez_names") %>% collect(), by = c("gene" = "entrez")) %>% .$name %>%
        paste0(collapse = "; ")
    }) -> df$gene_names
  df %>% dplyr::rename(enriched_gene_ids = leadingEdge) %>% 
    mutate(enriched_gene_ids = map_chr(enriched_gene_ids, function(x) paste0(x, collapse = " ")))
}

tab_S18 <- GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA %>% 
  filter(Species == "am" & pvalue < 0.05) %>%
  arrange(Test_type, pvalue) %>%
  select(-Species, -ES, -nMoreExtreme, -size) %>%
  add_name_col() 

saveRDS(tab_S18 %>% select(-enriched_gene_ids, -gene_names), file = "supplement/tab_S18.rds")
kable.table(tab_S18)

tab_S19 <- GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA %>% 
  filter(Species == "bt" & pvalue < 0.05) %>%
  arrange(Test_type, pvalue) %>%
  select(-Species, -ES, -nMoreExtreme, -size) %>%
  add_name_col() 

saveRDS(tab_S19 %>% select(-enriched_gene_ids, -gene_names), file = "supplement/tab_S19.rds")
kable.table(tab_S19)

tab_S20 <- GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA %>% 
  filter(Species == "lf" & pvalue < 0.05) %>%
  arrange(Test_type, pvalue) %>%
  select(-Species, -ES, -nMoreExtreme, -size) %>%
  add_name_col() 

saveRDS(tab_S20 %>% select(-enriched_gene_ids, -gene_names), file = "supplement/tab_S20.rds")
kable.table(tab_S20)

tab_S21 <- GO_and_KEGG_results_GSEA %>% 
  filter(Species == "ln" & pvalue < 0.05) %>%
  arrange(Test_type, pvalue) %>%
  select(-Species, -ES, -nMoreExtreme, -size) %>%
  add_name_col() 

saveRDS(tab_S21 %>% select(-enriched_gene_ids, -gene_names), file = "supplement/tab_S21.rds")
kable.table(tab_S21)

GO and KEGG enrichment for differentially spliced genes

This section uses a metric that measures the sensitivity of alternative splicing to pheromone treatment (referred to in the code below as sensitivity). This metric is calculated by finding the highest and lowest log fold change in expression among the isoforms for gene \(i\), and then taking the difference. For example, a gene with two isoform, with log fold change values of -1 and +3, would have a sensitivity value of 4. In the following code, we calculate sensitivity for all of the genes which A) have orthologs in all 4 species, and B) have 2 or more isoforms. We then calculate the Spearman correlation in sensitivity across genes for each species pair, and also perform GSEA (as was previously done for the data on pheromone sensitivity).

# Calculate splicing sensitivity for Apis:
am_isoforms <- tbl(my_db, "ebseq_isoform_am") %>%
  left_join(tbl(my_db, "isoforms_am"), by = "isoform") %>% 
  arrange(gene) %>% collect()
# Discard genes with only one splice variant
keep <- am_isoforms %>% group_by(gene) %>% summarise(n_isoforms = n()) %>% filter(n_isoforms > 1) %>% .$gene 
am_isoforms <- am_isoforms %>% filter(gene %in% keep) %>%
  select(gene, PPDE, PostFC) 
# Splicing index is max - min of the log(FC) for the isoforms of the focal gene
am.splice <- am_isoforms %>% 
  split(.$gene) %>%
  purrr::map_dbl(function(x){
    max(log(x$PostFC)) - min(log(x$PostFC))
  }) 
am.splice <- data.frame(gene = names(am.splice),
                        sensitivity = unname(am.splice), stringsAsFactors = FALSE) %>%
  arrange(-sensitivity)

# Calculate splicing sensitivity for the other 3 species. Here, there is an extra step: map the genes to their Apis orthologs
get_splice_score <- function(sp){
  tabl <- paste("ebseq_isoform_", sp, sep = "")
  iso.table <- paste("isoforms_", sp, sep = "")
  ortho.table <- make.OGGs(c("am", sp))[[2]]
  
  isoforms <- tbl(my_db, tabl) %>%
    left_join(tbl(my_db, iso.table), by = "isoform") %>% collect(n=Inf) %>%
    arrange(gene) %>% 
    left_join(ortho.table, by = c("gene" = sp)) %>%
    select(-gene) %>% dplyr::rename(gene = am) %>%
    filter(!is.na(gene)) %>% collect()
  
  keep <- isoforms %>% group_by(gene) %>% summarise(n_isoforms = n()) %>% filter(n_isoforms > 1) %>% .$gene 
  
  isoforms <- isoforms %>% filter(gene %in% keep) %>%
    select(gene, PPDE, PostFC) 
  
  isoforms <- isoforms %>% 
    split(.$gene) %>%
    purrr::map_dbl(function(x){
      max(log(x$PostFC)) - min(log(x$PostFC))
    }) 
  data.frame(gene = names(isoforms), 
             sensitivity = unname(isoforms), stringsAsFactors = FALSE) %>%
    arrange(-sensitivity)
}

# Get the splicing index for all 4 species, and restrict to the set of genes that have orthologs in all 4 species 
splice_scores <- list(am.splice, 
                      get_splice_score("bt"), 
                      get_splice_score("lf"), 
                      get_splice_score("ln"))

# Find the correlations between each species pair in the splicing index
splicing_correlations <- data.frame(t(combn(1:4, 2)), rho = 0, p = 0) %>% 
  dplyr::rename(Species1 = X1, Species2 = X2)
for(i in 1:nrow(splicing_correlations)){
  focal <- left_join(splice_scores[[splicing_correlations[i, 1]]], 
                     splice_scores[[splicing_correlations[i, 2]]], by="gene")
  focal <- focal[complete.cases(focal), ]
  test <- with(focal, cor.test(sensitivity.x, sensitivity.y, method = "spearman"))
  splicing_correlations$rho[i] <- test$estimate
  splicing_correlations$p[i] <- test$p.value
}
splicing_correlations[,1] <- c("Apis mellifera", "Bombus terrestris", "Lasius flavus", "Lasius niger")[splicing_correlations[,1]]
splicing_correlations[,2] <- c("Apis mellifera", "Bombus terrestris", "Lasius flavus", "Lasius niger")[splicing_correlations[,2]]
splicing_correlations$p.adjust <- p.adjust(splicing_correlations$p, method = "BH")
splicing_correlations$sig <- " "
splicing_correlations$sig[splicing_correlations$p.adjust < 0.05] <- "*"

# Perform GSEA on the splicing index
GO_and_KEGG_splicing_GSEA <- rbind(
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea(df = splice_scores[[1]], keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "am"),
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea(df = splice_scores[[2]], keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "bt"), 
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea(df = splice_scores[[3]], keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "lf"), 
  GO.and.KEGG.gsea(df = splice_scores[[4]], keep.all = TRUE) %>% mutate(Species = "ln")) %>%
  fill_in_GSEA_results() 

saveRDS(splicing_correlations, file = "supplement/tab_S22.rds")
splicing_correlations %>% pander(split.cell = 40, split.table = Inf)

fig_S5 <- GO_and_KEGG_splicing_GSEA %>% make_enrichment_heatmap()
saveRDS(fig_S5, file = "supplement/fig_S5.rds")
fig_S5 %>% grid.draw()

tab_S23 <- GO_and_KEGG_splicing_GSEA %>% 
  filter(pvalue < 0.05) %>%
  arrange(Species, Test_type, pvalue) %>%
  select(-ES, -nMoreExtreme, -size) %>%
  add_name_col() 

saveRDS(tab_S23 %>% select(-gene_names, -enriched_gene_ids), file = "supplement/tab_S23.rds")
kable.table(tab_S23)